C:\UPSC\GS4\2016\Q-8.txt
Case Studies on Ethical DilemmasEXAMINEYear 201620 Marks
Concept / Statute•Directive•Institution / Stakeholder

Case Study: You are an honest superintendent of police. An innocent young man from a minority community is arrested by your subordinate officers on suspicion of involvement in a bomb blast. Under interrogation torture, the youth confesses to the crime. However, independent forensic and call record evidence clearly establishes that he was 500 km away during the blast. Your senior officers urge you to keep him in custody to show swift police progress to the media. (a) What are the ethical and legal violations in this case? (b) How will you ensure justice for the innocent youth while disciplining your officers?

Exact Syllabus Pointer

Case studies on problems of integrity, conflict of interest, crisis management, political pressure, social boycott, ethical dilemmas in public office.

Connected Questions Across All Papers

Discovered through overlapping concepts: Custodial Torture & False Confession, Minority Scapegoating, Police Accountability

Recurring Theme Trend: “Custodial Torture & False Confession”

8 questions across 14 yrs

Frequency of UPSC CSE Mains questions testing this core concept, landmark doctrine, or foundational syllabus theme (2013-2026)

20131
20141
20151
20161
20170
20181
20190
20201
20210
20221
20230
20241
20250
20260
HomeExploreSearchMy Vault